Books & Comics Fangirl

Goodbye Gail Simone

GailSimoneThis past weekend, comic book writer Gail Simone let the news drop on Twitter that she had been removed from DC’s New 52 Batgirl title. It’s shocking that DC would give Gail the boot after the acclaim that Batgirl has received since the reboot, but the most shocking part of this story is how they broke the news to Gail. The fired her VIA EMAIL.

I have been a DC fangirl since before I can remember. Batman and Wonder Woman helped to shape my childhood and created a lifelong loyalty to Detective Comics. I’ve followed the story lines of every major event, each retcon, each death and inevitable resurrection, and I even stood by them through the New 52 reboot. Hell, I DEFENDED them to scores of my fellow fans. I kept the faith!

I cannot express how disappointing it is to learn that DC has less class than some of my asshole ex-boyfriends. At least they had the courtesy to pick up the phone to end things.

barbara-gordon-oracle-geek-draftGail has done an incredible job with Barbara Gordon for many years. She created an incredibly strong character in Birds of Prey who rose above her physical disability and continued to be a hero. As Oracle, Barbara showed the world that knowledge and smarts were the most powerful tools a crime fighter had, and she became an icon for fans with disabilities themselves.

When DC rebooted their universe, Gail was given the chance to write Barbara again, but there was a catch. Barbara was to be returned to her original role as Batgirl, and taken out of her now-trademark wheelchair. Fans were in an uproar. Some were thrilled to see Babs’ red hair under the cowl again. Others were furious to lose an idol with an incredible story of courage that impacted so many characters in the DC universe. Amid this controversy, Gail wrote Batgirl_Vol_1Babs brilliantly. She embraced Barbara’s history, and wrote Batgirl to show the struggles of someone recovering from life changing injuries and PTSD. Gail even researched Barbara’s conditions by seeking the advice of Dr. Andrea Letamendi, an avid comic book fan and doctor of psychology (and my cosplay friend!), to insure that Barbara’s recovery was accurately depicted. Gail’s incredible respect for Barbara won over fans in both camps and turned Batgirl from one of the most hated reboots in the New 52, into one of its best selling titles.

I’m a huge fan of Gail’s writing, her outspoken views about how women are depicted in comics, her support of cosplaying, and her amazing relationship with her fans. I’ve only met (read:seen) her briefly in line at conventions, but she is always smiling and kind to her fans… and she liked my steampunk Batgirl cosplay!! It’s hard to think that she was so difficult to work with that they had no other option than to fire her. It makes me sad to think that she may never write my favorite DC heroines again.

No official reasons for her termination have been released. I can see her refusing to put “women in refrigerators” despite what her DC superiors wanted, and indeed, there have been some tweets hinting that is exactly what led to her getting fired. Regardless of the reason, after an average of 40,000 Batgirl copies sold each month, DC and Brian Cunningham (the new editor of Batgirl) owed Gail a phone call at the very least.

Shame on you, DC.

 UPDATE 10/21/2012: Today, Gail Simone has announced that DC has rehired her as the writer for Batgirl. I think it’s safe to say that the fan’s voices were heard on this issue. I wonder if they notified her via email…

About the author

Kimi

Kimi (aka GoldenLassoGirl) is known for her cosplays, comic book knowledge, and tabletop gaming podcast/stream. Read more about her at http://www.goldenlasso.net/about/

Leave a Reply

6 Comments

Click here to post a comment

  • I just read this, coming off as I just have from reading similar comments about atrocious communication style on a LinkedIn group for LinkedIn Group Product Managers. While I tend to facepalm on the stories of such stories with the socially inept and pallid, I am shocked to see this happen at National/DC/Warner whatever…

    Comic books exist specifically for expression and communication from EC to RipOff Press to Zap to the more mainstream (and genteel and post-Kefauver sensitive) DCs and Marvels and Archies. More than any other medium, IMHO, communications sensitivity should exist here where image and meaning mesh with words and duotone. So it is with shock, rather than my typical indignant amusement I read about this eMail firing, which breaks the rudist-mentary of basic HR management concepts. And I am only left to wonder under what management, which would hire Brian Cunningham in the first place, Ms. Simone toils.

    Holy Incredulity Batman!

  • Id like to point out that throughout all this, she has never once bagged on DC despite their treatment of her. She talks about being shocked and saddened and in tears, but never once does she lower herself to slam DC.

    It really proves what a great person she is. It makes DC look even worse for their treatment of her and I admire her even more. In the end, its DC’s loss.

    What a classy lady!

Streaming Schedule & Events